Philosophers / Charles Taylor
Contemporary

Charles Taylor

1931 – ?
Montreal, Canada
Phenomenology political philosophy ethics philosophy of religion philosophy of social science epistemology history of philosophy

Charles Taylor is a Canadian philosopher whose work on selfhood, modernity, secularism, and multiculturalism has made him one of the most important political and moral philosophers of the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. His magisterial *Sources of the Self* traces the emergence of the modern identity, while *A Secular Age* provides the most comprehensive philosophical account of how Western societies moved from a world where belief in God was axiomatic to one where it is merely one option among many.

Key Ideas

Politics of recognition, sources of the self, secular age, strong evaluations, social imaginaries

Key Contributions

  • Traced the historical emergence of the modern identity through multiple moral sources in Sources of the Self
  • Provided the most comprehensive philosophical account of secularization in the Latin West in A Secular Age
  • Developed the concept of the 'politics of recognition' — that democratic politics must acknowledge the distinctive identity of cultural groups
  • Defended hermeneutic social science against reductive naturalism, arguing that human action requires interpretive understanding
  • Articulated the 'immanent frame' as the shared context within which both belief and unbelief become live options in modernity
  • Made Hegel's communitarian insights accessible to English-speaking philosophy

Core Questions

How did the modern sense of selfhood — characterized by inwardness, authenticity, and the affirmation of ordinary life — emerge?
Why did Western societies move from universal belief in God to a plurality of spiritual options?
What does justice require in multicultural societies with diverse conceptions of the good?
Is naturalistic social science adequate to explain human action, or does understanding require hermeneutic interpretation?
What moral sources sustain the modern identity, and can a secular age find sufficient resources for ethical life?
What is the relationship between recognition and identity in democratic politics?

Key Claims

  • The modern identity is constituted by multiple, often conflicting moral sources: theism, Enlightenment reason, and Romantic expressivism
  • Secularization is not simply the subtraction of religion but a transformation of the conditions of belief
  • The 'immanent frame' is the shared context of modernity within which belief and unbelief are both live options
  • Misrecognition or nonrecognition can be a form of oppression; democratic politics must accommodate cultural difference
  • Individuals are constituted by their social and cultural contexts — the atomistic self of liberal theory is a fiction
  • Hermeneutic understanding is irreducible to naturalistic explanation in the human sciences

Biography

Early Life and Education

Charles Margrave Taylor was born on November 5, 1931, in Montreal, Quebec, Canada, to a bilingual family (English-speaking father, French-speaking mother). This bicultural upbringing in a multicultural society profoundly shaped his lifelong concern with questions of identity, recognition, and pluralism.

Taylor studied history and political science at McGill University before going to Oxford as a Rhodes Scholar, where he earned his D.Phil. under the supervision of Isaiah Berlin and Elizabeth Anscombe. At Oxford, he engaged deeply with the Anglo-Saxon analytic tradition while also immersing himself in Continental philosophy — Hegel, Merleau-Ponty, Heidegger — creating a synthesis unusual among English-language philosophers.

The Explanation of Behaviour and Hermeneutic Philosophy

The Explanation of Behaviour (1964), Taylor's first major work, challenged the behaviorist account of human action, arguing that teleological (purpose-directed) explanation is indispensable and irreducible to mechanistic causal explanation. This defense of hermeneutic over naturalistic social science became a recurring theme.

Hegel and the History of Philosophy

Hegel (1975) and Hegel and Modern Society (1979) provided influential interpretations that made Hegel accessible to English-speaking audiences. Taylor emphasized Hegel's communitarian insights: that individuals are constituted by their social and cultural contexts and that freedom requires recognition by and participation in a community — themes that would become central to Taylor's own philosophy.

Sources of the Self (1989)

Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity (1989) is Taylor's philosophical masterpiece. It traces the historical emergence of the distinctively modern sense of selfhood — characterized by inwardness, the affirmation of ordinary life, and the ideal of authenticity — from its roots in Augustine's inward turn, through the Reformation's sanctification of daily life, Descartes' disengaged reason, the Romantic expressivism of Herder and the Romantics, and the modernist confrontation with meaninglessness.

Taylor argued that the modern self draws on multiple, often conflicting "moral sources" — theism, Enlightenment reason, Romantic expressivism — and that acknowledging this plurality is essential to understanding our moral predicament. He also argued against "subtraction narratives" that picture modernity as simply the removal of religion, proposing instead that secularization involves a transformation of the conditions of belief.

A Secular Age (2007)

A Secular Age (2007) is Taylor's most ambitious work: an 874-page history of secularization in the Latin West. Taylor asks why it was virtually impossible not to believe in God in 1500 and entirely possible in 2000. His answer rejects both simple "subtraction stories" (religion just fades as reason advances) and purely sociological explanations. Instead, Taylor traces how the "conditions of belief" changed through a series of historical transformations: the disenchantment of the world, the creation of "buffered" selves impervious to spiritual forces, the Nova effect (the multiplication of spiritual options), and the emergence of an "immanent frame" within which both belief and unbelief become live options.

Multiculturalism and the Politics of Recognition

"The Politics of Recognition" (1994) argued that modern democratic politics must grapple with the demand for recognition — the acknowledgment of the distinctive identity of cultural, ethnic, and religious groups. Misrecognition or nonrecognition can be a form of oppression, and liberal democracies must find ways to accommodate cultural difference without abandoning universal principles of equal dignity.

Taylor has held positions at McGill University for most of his career and has been awarded the Templeton Prize, the Kyoto Prize, and the Berggruen Prize, among many others.

Methods

hermeneutic philosophy historical genealogy phenomenological description communitarianism intellectual history

Notable Quotes

"{'text': 'The demand for recognition is given urgency by the supposed links between recognition and identity.', 'source': 'The Politics of Recognition', 'year': 1994}"
"{'text': "We are all framed within what I want to call the 'immanent frame.'", 'source': 'A Secular Age', 'year': 2007}"
"{'text': 'Our identity is partly shaped by recognition or its absence, often by the misrecognition of others.', 'source': 'The Politics of Recognition', 'year': 1994}"
"{'text': 'To know who I am is a species of knowing where I stand.', 'source': 'Sources of the Self', 'year': 1989}"

Major Works

  • The Explanation of Behaviour Book (1964)
  • Hegel Book (1975)
  • Sources of the Self Book (1989)
  • The Ethics of Authenticity Book (1991)
  • The Politics of Recognition Essay (1994)
  • A Secular Age Book (2007)
  • The Language Animal Book (2016)

Influenced

Influenced by

Sources

  • Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  • Charles Taylor (Abbey, 2000)
  • The Cambridge Companion to Charles Taylor (forthcoming)
  • Charles Taylor: Meaning, Morals and Modernity (Smith, 2002)

External Links

Translations

Portuguese
100%
Spanish
100%
Italian
100%

Discussions

No discussions yet.

Compare:
Compare